Property Rights in Second Marriages: Rights of Second Wives and Children under Hindu Law

The Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 and the Hindu Succession Act of 1955, respectively, set down the rights of a wife and her children in relation to the husband’s property. The interactions between a second wife and her children, though, can be different.

The Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act of 1956 and the Hindu Succession Act of 1956 must be acknowledged when discussing a divorced woman’s rights on her husband’s property. The provisions of these acts grant women complete control over their husband’s assets following his passing. Even in the event of her remarriage or choice to adopt, the rights cannot be reduced or disputed. If the husband marries again, there are various subtleties that come into play. If the second wife and her kids don’t fit the legal requirements, their rights may be contested.

Second wife’s legal rights to her husband’s property 

We must first look at the legitimacy of the second marriage in order to ascertain the second wife’s rights. Polygamy is forbidden by the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955. The act stipulates that neither party may be officially married at the time of the second marriage and that both parties must dissolve their first marriage before getting married again. Hence, the second wife does not qualify for a portion of the husband’s property if this requirement is not satisfied.

Also, the second wife has the same rights as the first wife over the husband’s property if the second marriage is valid, that is, if the husband marries after the death of the first wife or after divorcing the first wife. This holds true for both the husband’s own property and his ancestors’ assets.

The laws governing the property rights of the first and second spouses and their offspring are quite complex, and the judge must rely on a number of different Government Acts to make a legal decision. These are a few situations where making a decision could prove challenging.

The legality of a husband’s property rights in various circumstances

Case I

A husband marries a second time without formally divorcing his first spouse

When the first wife and their children from the marriage are still living and the husband gets remarried without divorcing the first wife, they are entitled to the property. Following the patriarch’s passing, the property will be equally divided amongst the first wife, her children, the children of the second wife, and in very rare circumstances, the second wife. Regarding the second wife’s rights in this case, there is some ambiguity.

Case II

After the death of his first wife, the husband marries again

The children from the first marriage and the children from the second marriage, as well as the second wife, have the right to equal interests in the patriarch’s property after his death when the husband remarries.

Case III

The husband remarries following the divorce

All parties, with the exception of the first wife, receive an equal share of the patriarch’s property when the husband remarries after divorcing his first wife. These parties include the children from the first marriage, the second wife, and the children from the second marriage.

Case IV 

The husband and his first wife co-own the property

The following situations can occur when the in question property is jointly owned and is marital property:

• Even after the husband’s second marriage, the first wife and her designated beneficiaries continue to be the legal proprietors of the property left over after the husband’s passing. Nonetheless, the Hindu Succession Act may be used by the offspring of the second marriage to assert a claim to a portion of the property.
• The second wife can make a claim on the property when the first wife passes away because the husband will then become the sole owner.

Rights of the second wife’s children to the husband’s property

• In the absence of a will or the owner’s intestate death, the Hindu Succession Law designates the following individuals as Class I legal heirs to the deceased person’s estates: the son, daughter, widow, mother, son of a predeceased son, daughter of a predeceased son, widow of a predeceased son, son of a predeceased daughter, daughter of a predeceased son, and son of a predeceased son.
• The father’s immovable property, which included both his own acquisitions and his inheritance, will therefore be divided equally among the children from the first and second marriages under the law.
• Remarriage without the legal culmination of the previous marriage is prohibited by the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955. So, if the second husband passes away without making a will, the second wife in those circumstances cannot claim any portion in the property of the deceased husband (intestate). Children from the second marriage, on the other hand, will be regarded as legitimate under Section 16 of the Act and will have the same claim to the father’s property as the children from his first marriage because, under the terms of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, children in both cases will be Class I legal heirs in the event that the father passes away intestate.
•  According to the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act of 1956, the second wife and her children are entitled to maintenance even in cases of illegitimate marriage.
• However, the second wife’s children from her prior marriages are not entitled to any of the deceased husband’s property.

As a result, the second wife’s property rights depend on the legitimacy of her marriage.

First wife’s property rights and inheritance after divorce or abandonment

The first wife and the children are still considered to be the legal heirs of the marriage if the first wife is abandoned or alienated, that is, left without a divorce. In certain situations, the second marriage is invalid, and the second wife has no legal claim to the husband’s inheritance or property. The offspring of the second wife, however, are entitled to the patriarch’s possessions.

Half-blood children’s property rights

Children of half-blood parents only have one biological parent; the other parent is either the mother’s other husband or the father’s other spouse. Property rights are granted to the heir closest to the property owner when a spouse has both biological and half-blood children. This scenario most frequently occurs after divorce or remarriage. Half-blood children are given secondary precedence over biological offspring in terms of ownership rights to property that belongs to the parent.

The children in both scenarios fundamentally have the right to the father’s immovable property, despite the fact that the ownership rights may appear to differ in the circumstances of first and second marriages. To avoid any unwanted situations, it is best to get in touch with a legal professional in the event of any inconsistencies.

Follow and Connect with us: Twitter, Facebook, Linkedin, Instagram